Sök i support

Akta dig för supportbedrägerier: Vi kommer aldrig att be dig att ringa eller skicka ett sms till ett telefonnummer eller dela personlig information. Rapportera misstänkt aktivitet med alternativet "Rapportera missbruk".

Läs mer

Help an old man migrate from Eudora after 20 years

  • 2 svar
  • 0 har detta problem
  • Senaste svar av tdaly

more options

I've been (mostly happily until 2 yrs ago) with Eudora. My usage model is to keep all (saved) email locally (20 yrs archive), access via POP. Unfortunately, the evolution of HTML, iso character sets, etc has been forcing me to move on. I tried TB about 2 yrs ago and abandoned the project for lack of time and urgency. I'm trying again, but now very serious. Anyway, I set up an install and did basic tests - all ok. But I can't seem to find config options to customize. I found some option to set my mail store to a folder of my choice (away from the system root -- C:\ - i use windows 10-11.) to something like E:\docs\tb. It created inbox, trash etc. right there. My previous install attempt (2 yrs ago) created these in a subfolder named for the email account (eudora calls 'personalities'). I do want to use multiple accounts each in their own 'garden', not in the same inbox, outbox, etc.. I can't find where to configure this - I can't even find how to configure my earlier choice to store them on E:. What am I missing? On some settings for copies and folders, it offers (eg) Sent folder on <email account>. I presume this is particular to IMAP and not relevant to my current setup.

That's enough to get me started, but I would like to eventually migrate my Eudora archives to TB, so a pointer to docs on this would be appreciated.

Tnx, Tom

I've been (mostly happily until 2 yrs ago) with Eudora. My usage model is to keep all (saved) email locally (20 yrs archive), access via POP. Unfortunately, the evolution of HTML, iso character sets, etc has been forcing me to move on. I tried TB about 2 yrs ago and abandoned the project for lack of time and urgency. I'm trying again, but now very serious. Anyway, I set up an install and did basic tests - all ok. But I can't seem to find config options to customize. I found some option to set my mail store to a folder of my choice (away from the system root -- C:\ - i use windows 10-11.) to something like E:\docs\tb. It created inbox, trash etc. right there. My previous install attempt (2 yrs ago) created these in a subfolder named for the email account (eudora calls 'personalities'). I do want to use multiple accounts each in their own 'garden', not in the same inbox, outbox, etc.. I can't find where to configure this - I can't even find how to configure my earlier choice to store them on E:. What am I missing? On some settings for copies and folders, it offers (eg) Sent folder on <email account>. I presume this is particular to IMAP and not relevant to my current setup. That's enough to get me started, but I would like to eventually migrate my Eudora archives to TB, so a pointer to docs on this would be appreciated. Tnx, Tom

Alla svar (2)

more options

I have been fielding questions about this product that I personally loathed back in the 1990s for much more than decade. I have also upset a lot of Eudora folk that will not accept that Eudora has some major weaknesses and this is one of the major reasons importing from it is so prone to failure.

Before you enter into using Thunderbird there are some thing I think need to be crystal clear.

  1. Thunderbird is not Eudora. Things are done differently and layouts are different. If you think you can make Thunderbird look like Eudora you probably need to go off and have a look at the resurrected Eudora project using the source Qualcomm released.
  2. Changing the default directory on a per account basis, while offered in account settings is a recipe for future failure. Do not do it.
  3. Do not try and place mail data in your documents, pictures or other system folder or the root of any drive. There is a high probability you will loose data when your antivurs of Microsoft backup corrupts the mail store.

Do not meddle in the Thunderbird profile folder with the mail storage. Again data loss is the most common outcome. Even I do not touch that stuff with Thunderbird running in the task manager. (the absence of a window does not mean that application is not still running)

Thunderbird stores mail in profiles. See https://support.mozilla.org/en-US/kb/profiles-where-thunderbird-stores-user-data it is via the profile manager you change the drive to use and the folders. A full location for the profile structure is what you set. But I do not recommend doing so until you have your data imported.

Do not install the Microsoft Store version of Thunderbird if you are gong to change the profile location. Personally I think it is poorly tested and no one really has the details of what the windows sandbox for store apps does to Thunderbird. They only think they do. I have seen no explicit testing involving the store version,m just an anjnouncement5 that it was released.

IMAP essentially does not have a local store worth mentioning. It caches copies locally, but as soon as there is a problem verifying the local copy with the server the local copy is deleted. So do not get caught.

The official docs, such as they were, were basically deleted when Qualcomm abandoned the Eudora OSE implementation. There are none and as you are over 10 years late getting to the party, there are few that actually were involved in support back then to even offer ideas. Thunderbird does not have any Eudora import code any longer, that has been purged from the code base probably about V34 f I recall correctly. However if you get an old enough version from here https://ftp.mozilla.org/pub/thunderbird/releases/ Perhaps V30 or 3.1 installing it on a system with a functional Eudora will see things just imported. Then you can update to a more recent version as those old versions do not work with major mail p0roviders any better than Eudora does. Mostly with regard to Oauth authentication and TLS encryption bnut you will not be able to get mail from Yahoo, Hotmail or Gmail with V3.1 any longer I do not think.

This information https://kb.mozillazine.org/Importing_from_Eudora_-_Thunderbird is still Germaine and the reference to Eudora rescue is often very relevant, not that I know if it is available anywhere on the web any longer. Despite a loyal user base, Eudora was really sloppy with it's stores and tolerant of errors caused by incorrect file edits. Something that sort of goes with an application that encourages manual file editing. Nothing since has even considered accepting a Eudora level of inherent corruption without major issues.

Hjälpsam?

more options

I wanted to thank you quickly (now) for your reply. There's a lot to digest there so I'm going to take the time rather than peppering with a bunch of not-well-thought-out questions...  :) tnx, tom

Hjälpsam?

Ställ en fråga

Du måste logga in på ditt konto för att svara på inlägg. Vänligen starta en ny fråga om du inte har ett konto ännu.